Is my damage worth claiming or not?

When your car has a dent, bumper scrape, or panel damage, deciding whether to lodge an insurance claim or pay privately comes down to comparing the total repair cost against your insurance policy excess and any impact on your no-claims bonus.

How to decide whether to claim on insurance

  • Check your policy excess: A standard NZ car insurance excess is typically between $400 and $1,000 (sometimes higher for drivers under 25). Modern bumper, sensor, headlamp, or multi-panel paint repairs often exceed $1,000 once brackets, calibration, and colour blending are included.
  • Not-at-fault accidents: If another driver hit your vehicle and you have their registration plate, name, and contact details, most NZ insurers waive your excess completely—making an insurance claim the clear choice.
  • Minor cosmetic scrapes or single dents: If the damage is smaller than or close to your excess amount, paying privately or using paintless dent removal (PDR) may be more cost-effective than lodging a claim.

Start with photos

Send us clear photos of the damage via our Get an Estimate Page or call 09 580 0323. Free for simple repairs we can price from photos. If it needs a closer look, a written quote is $100 + GST, taken off your bill if you repair with us.

Get Estimate & Advice

Ask us a question